Cleansing Away the Day: A Roundup of the Best Makeup Removers of 2024

Best Makeup Remover
Written by:
Updated on:
September 24, 2024
Beauty Care Insider may receive an affiliate commission for purchases made through certain product links on our site.

Finding the right makeup remover is crucial in keeping your skin healthy and fresh. Whether you have oily skin, combination skin, or dry patches, there’s a perfect solution out there for you. From oil cleansers rich in nourishing seed oil to gentle face wipes, incorporating the right product into your skincare routine can make all the difference in removing your makeup effectively and maintaining your skin’s balance.

Understanding your skin’s needs is the first step in choosing a makeup remover that works for you. For those with oily skin, products designed to remove excess oil without stripping the skin are ideal. Meanwhile, combination skin types might look for versatile solutions that address both dry and oily areas. No matter your skin type, the goal is a clean, refreshed face at the end of your skincare routine.

What are the different types of makeup removers?

There’s a variety of makeup removers to fit every skincare routine and skin type, including oily skin and combination skin. Options range from convenient face wipes for quick cleansing to thorough oil-based formulas. Choosing the right type not only effectively clears your face of makeup but also complements your skincare routine, enhancing your skin’s health and appearance.

Cleansing oils

Cleansing oils are a fantastic choice for dissolving stubborn makeup while keeping the skin nourished. They work wonders on oily skin and combination skin alike, as they can remove excess sebum without over-drying. Integrating an oil-based product into your skincare routine can transform your makeup removal process into a soothing, skin-enriching ritual.

Micellar water

Micellar water is celebrated for its simplicity and effectiveness, needing only a cotton round to whisk away the day’s makeup. Its tiny micelles latch onto dirt, oil, and makeup, removing them gently without requiring harsh rubbing. This makes it a go-to for those seeking a quick, efficient makeup removal method that leaves the skin feeling clean and refreshed.

Cleansing balms

Cleansing balms combine the efficiency of makeup removal with the skin-care benefits of moisturizers like vitamin E, leaving your skin without a greasy residue. They’re designed to melt upon contact, dissolving even the most stubborn makeup and brightening the skin. Unlike other cleansers, they ensure your face is left feeling soft, supple, and hydrated.

Milk cleansers

Milk cleansers stand out for their gentle yet effective approach to makeup removal, especially when tackling stubborn waterproof makeup. The combination of cleansing oils in a makeup-removing cleansing balm format can deeply cleanse while maintaining the skin’s natural moisture barrier. This makes them ideal for those seeking a mild yet powerful cleansing option.

Makeup remover wipes

For those with a busy lifestyle or oily skin, makeup remover wipes offer a convenient and effective solution. They’re perfect for on-the-go makeup removal, helping to control oil while refreshing the face. However, it’s important to follow up with a deeper cleanse to ensure all traces of makeup and impurities are removed from the skin.

How to choose the best makeup remover for your skin?

When selecting a makeup remover, consider your skin type first. For oily skin, cleansing oil can actually help regulate oil production, contrary to popular belief. An oil-based cleanser or makeup cleansing balm enriched with natural ingredients can effectively remove makeup without leaving your skin feeling greasy. Micellar waters are a gentle, no-rinse option that effectively remove makeup without irritating sensitive skin or leaving any residue behind.

Cleansing balms are another popular choice, as they melt away makeup while providing a deep cleanse without stripping the skin’s barrier. These balms often contain nourishing ingredients like oils and butters, making them ideal for dry or mature skin types. Milk cleansers offer a creamy, gentle solution for removing makeup while simultaneously cleansing the skin, leaving it feeling soft and hydrated.

For those seeking convenience, makeup remover wipes are a quick and easy option for taking off makeup on-the-go or before your full cleansing routine. However, it’s important to choose wipes that are gentle enough for your skin type and don’t leave any residue behind.

Ultimately, understanding your skin’s needs and experimenting with different oil-based formulas can help you find the perfect makeup remover. Remember, the goal is to leave your skin clean, balanced, and healthy.

Best cleansing oils

Credit: DHC

For anyone seeking a gentle yet effective makeup remover, the DHC Deep Cleansing Oil, stands out as the top choice. It melts away makeup, dissolves impurities, and leaves skin clean, soft, and radiant. Its 100% organic olive oil base binds with dirt and breaks down sunscreen, sebum, and stubborn makeup without leaving an oily residue. The water-soluble formula, enriched with antioxidant-rich vitamin E and invigorating rosemary leaf oil, rinses off easily, leaving a silky feel. Suitable for all skin types, it’s also a handy makeup brush cleaner. 

Pros
100% organic olive oil-based formulation
Suitable for all skin types
Can also be used to clean makeup brushes
Cons
Price range may be considered high for some budgets

Credit: Sulwhasoo

For individuals struggling with excess sebum, Sulwhasoo Gentle Cleansing Oil stands out as the top pick for effectively controlling oil while ensuring deep-pore cleansing. This product not only removes impurities like fine dust and stubborn waterproof makeup but also leaves your skin feeling incredibly fresh and thoroughly cleansed. Its magic lies in the yeonsum, a traditional Korean herbal oil complex that not only keeps your skin firm but also tightens pores for a smoother appearance. Ingredients such as pinus koraiensis seed extract and camelia japonica seed oil work together to offer a gentle yet powerful cleansing experience. It’s HET-CAM (eye irritation potential) and dermatologically tested, ensuring safety and efficacy.

Pros
Utilizes a unique Korean herbal oil complex, yeonsum, for firmer skin and tighter pores
Formulated with natural ingredients like pinus koraiensis seed extract and camelia japonica seed oil
HET-CAM and dermatologically tested, ensuring safety and efficacy
Cons
May not be suitable for all skin types, particularly those sensitive to specific oils or fragrances

Best micellar waters

Credit: Garnier

If you’re seeking an all-in-one solution that caters to any skin type, Garnier Micellar Cleansing Water All-in-1 is your go-to for effortlessly removing makeup and purifying your skin. As America’s #1 Micellar Brand, it’s designed to deeply cleanse, refresh, and remove makeup without harsh rubbing. The micelles act like a magnet to lift away dirt, oil, and makeup, leaving your skin feeling clean and refreshed without over-drying.

You can find this product in three convenient sizes, with friendly prices, making it accessible for daily use. It’s gentle enough for sensitive skin and free of oil, alcohol, and fragrance. Plus, there’s no need to rinse, simplifying your skincare routine.

Pros
Micellar technology provides a deep cleanse without harsh rubbing or over-drying the skin
Versatile usage, not only for removing makeup but also for cleaning makeup brushes and removing hair color stains
No rinsing required, making it an easy addition to any skincare routine, morning or night
Cons
May not be as effective for waterproof makeup removal without additional effort

Credit: Medik8

Medik8 Eyes & Lips Micellar Cleanse offers a hassle-free solution that dissolves even the toughest of mascaras while conditioning your lashes and skin. It’s a triple-phase micellar technology that ensures superior makeup removal without any harsh pulling or tugging. You’ll find your skin soft, purified, and refreshed after use. The inclusion of vitamin B5, hyaluronic acid, chamomile, and cornflower helps to soothe and nourish, leaving no greasy residue behind. Whether you’re using it on your lashes or your entire face, you can expect a gentle yet effective cleanse suitable for all skin types. With Medik8, you’re not just removing makeup; you’re caring for your skin’s health and comfort.

Pros
Specifically formulated to dissolve waterproof makeup effortlessly
Contains nourishing ingredients like vitamin B5 and hyaluronic acid for skin and lash health
Cons
Price may be a bit steep for some budgets

Best cleansing balms

Credit: Elemis

For skincare enthusiasts seeking a deep cleanse without compromising nourishment, the Elemis Pro-Collagen Cleansing Balm stands out with its transformative 3-in-1 texture. This balm effortlessly turns into a cleansing oil and then to a milky solution, ensuring your skin is not just clean but also soft and nourished. Infused with ingredients like padina pavonica, mimosa flower wax, and starflower oil, it’s no wonder users rave about its effectiveness and luxurious feel.

You’ll enjoy a spa-like experience right at home, with the added bonus of efficiently removing makeup. Don’t forget, if you’re new to this product, trying out smaller sizes first can be a wise move, especially if you’re sensitive to fragrances. Plus, leaving the balm on for about 10 minutes before rinsing off can enhance its efficacy, making your skin feel exceptionally smooth and rejuvenated.

Pros
Transforms from a balm to oil to milk, providing a versatile cleansing experience
Formulated with nourishing ingredients like padina pavonica and starflower oil
Positive feedback on effectiveness, including makeup removal and skin softening
Cons
Higher price point may not be suitable for all budgets

Credit: Farmacy

This balm effortlessly removes makeup and gently exfoliates with papaya extract, revealing a youthful glow. Its refreshing scent comes from lime, bergamot, and orange essential oils, making the cleansing process a rejuvenating experience. It’s also TSA-approved, making it perfect for travel, and its jar is 100% recyclable, supporting sustainability. With key ingredients like sunflower and ginger root oils, turmeric, moringa extract, and papaya enzymes, it lifts impurities without stripping your skin.

Pros
Contains natural ingredients like papaya extract for exfoliation and a blend of essential oils
Eco-friendly packaging with a 100% recyclable jar
Cons
May be considered expensive compared to other cleansers in the market

Best milk cleansers

Credit: Kate Somerville

Opting for the Kate Somerville Goat Milk Moisturizing Cleanser is a prime choice for those seeking to gently remove makeup while hydrating sensitive skin. This cleanser combines the soothing properties of goat milk, manuka honey, jojoba, and avocado oils to relieve skin tightness and dryness, making it an ideal daily solution. It’s specifically formulated to be safe for sensitive skin, with a focus on delivering transformative results without irritation. The full list of ingredients, including natural oils and lactic acid, underscores a commitment to skin health and moisture. 

Pros
Gently cleanses the skin without stripping its natural oils
Contains natural and soothing ingredients like goat milk, manuka honey, jojoba, and avocado oils
Clinically tested and proven safe for sensitive skin
Cons
May be more expensive than other cleansers available on the market

Credit: Milk Makeup

Individuals with normal to dry or sensitive skin will find the Milk Makeup Vegan Milk Cleanser a hydrating and gentle choice for removing makeup and impurities. This sulfate-free face wash is crafted with a blend of vegan milks, ensuring your skin isn’t stripped of its natural oils while washing away the day’s dirt. It’s a vegan, clean, and cruelty-free product, free from parabens, silicones, fragrance, gluten, sulfates, phthalates, and talc. Its pH level, between 5.5-6.5, is designed to balance your skin’s natural pH. Its key ingredients, including Desert Milk™, fig milk, shea butter, oat milk, argan milk, grapeseed oil, and squalane, not only hydrate but also provide antioxidant benefits, leaving your skin soft, soothed, and moisturized.

Pros
Suitable for sensitive skin
Formulated with a variety of hydrating vegan milks and rich in antioxidants
Free from parabens, silicones, fragrance, gluten, sulfates, phthalates, and talc
Maintains skin’s natural pH balance with a pH level between 5.5-6.5
Cons
May not be as effective in removing mascara or waterproof makeup without double cleansing

Best makeup remover wipes

Credit: Neutrogena

These towelettes are made with a gentle formula that easily removes makeup, dirt, oil, and sunscreen from your face. The 100% plant-based cloth is soft on your skin and dissolves impurities without leaving any residue.

Pros
Ultra-soft texture
Effective in removing all types of makeup including waterproof mascara
Gentle formula suitable for sensitive skin
Alcohol-free
Cons
May dry out quickly if not sealed properly after use
Some users may experience a slight stinging sensation around the eye area
Not suitable as a replacement for traditional cleansers for everyday use

Credit: Ursa Major

These award-winning face wipes are perfect for keeping your skin feeling refreshed and firm even when you’re on-the-go. The 4-in-1 essential face tonic formula removes oil and grime, brightens dull-looking skin, soothes and hydrates all at once. Aloe helps to soothe and hydrate the skin while birch sap reduces the appearance of redness and uneven skin tone.

If you have oily or combination skin, these face wipes are an excellent choice for removing makeup or just refreshing your complexion throughout the day. They’re convenient to use whenever you need them and won’t leave any residue behind that could contribute to breakouts or clogged pores. Plus, they’re cruelty-free and vegan so you can feel good about using them on your skin.

Pros
Cleanses, exfoliates & hydrates in one step
Convenient for on-the-go use
Natural ingredients are gentle on oily or combination skin
Cons
Not as effective for heavy makeup removal
May not be suitable for those with sensitive skin
Individual packaging may generate more trash

Best practices for effective makeup removal

Start with eye makeup removal, especially if you wear waterproof mascara. Using a dedicated eye makeup remover can prevent harsh rubbing and potential irritation. This step ensures that the delicate area around your eyes is treated with care.

Use gentle circular motions for effective cleansing across your face. This technique helps to lift makeup and impurities without pulling or tugging at your skin, making the cleansing process both effective and soothing.

The double cleansing method is particularly beneficial for removing waterproof makeup. Begin with an oil-based cleanser to break down stubborn makeup, followed by a water-based cleanser to remove any remaining residues. This ensures a thorough clean without stripping your skin of its natural oils.

By incorporating these practices into your skincare routine, you can achieve a more effective and gentle makeup removal process. This not only keeps your skin healthy but also makes the end-of-day cleanse something to look forward to.

Questions you may have

Is makeup remover the same as cleanser?

Makeup remover and cleanser serve different roles in your skincare routine. A makeup remover is designed to dissolve makeup, even the types that typically wear for hours, like waterproof mascara. It uses special ingredients to make makeup melt away. On the other hand, a gel cleanser or a face cleanser helps to wash my face, removing dirt, oil, and the traces of makeup that the remover loosens but doesn’t fully remove. While some products can remove waterproof makeup, a face cleanser is more about cleaning the skin after the makeup is gone.

How to remove stubborn waterproof makeup without irritation?

To tackle stubborn waterproof makeup without causing irritation, start with a product like micellar cleansing water, which gently removes makeup without harsh rubbing. For more sensitive areas, such as the eyes, a formula enriched with hyaluronic acid can help hydrate the skin while effectively removing makeup. Always use gentle, circular motions and a soft cotton pad to minimize any risk of irritation.

How often should you replace your makeup remover product?

It’s important to keep your makeup remover products fresh. Generally, liquid makeup removers should be replaced every six months to a year, ensuring they remain effective at removing traces of makeup and nourishing your skin. If you have oily or acne-prone skin, consider replacing your products more frequently to avoid breakouts. 

Related Articles

  • Best Makeup Remover Balm
    September 21, 2024

    Melt Away Makeup With Ease Using the Best Cleansing Balms of 2024

  • Best Milk Cleanser
    August 11, 2024

    The Best of Both Worlds: 14 Milk Cleansers That Remove Makeup and Hydrate

  • Oil Based Makeup Remover
    September 22, 2024

    Oil-Based Makeup Remover: The Best Cleansing Oils of 2024 to Remove Makeup and Dirt

  • Micellar Water Makeup Remover
    September 12, 2024

    Why Micellar Water Is the Ultimate Cleanser and Makeup Remover for Clean, Fresh Skin

  • Best Makeup Remover Wipes
    September 22, 2024

    Discover the Best Makeup Remover Wipes for Effortless Cleanse

Return
To Top